I don't know what you are using this for but the second one has some great products in it. it also has a sunscreen. retinyl is good to help build collagen, vit k and vit e are both good for the face. aloe vera is a proven aid to help burns and sooth minor cuts and scrapes. this does have some 'cones' in it. cyclomethicone and dimethicone so it might be clogging to some people. it looks like a good product for moiturising and anti aging. i don't know some of the ingredients in the first. so i would say the second.